Affiliate Marketing in the Age of AI: Why Authenticity is the New Authority

AI is Rewriting the Rules of Affiliate Discovery—But the Human Touch Still Wins Out

We’re standing at the cusp of a new era in affiliate marketing…

AI is reshaping how consumers discover products and how brands and partners connect—but while AI can power discovery, only authenticity can build trust.

Here’s how affiliates, creators, and brands can thrive in the age of AI without losing the human touch.

From Matchmaking to Machine Learning

Affiliate marketing has always been about matchmaking—connecting the right brand with the right creator through painstaking manual effort and careful relationship-building.

Now however, we’re entering a new phase—one where AI doesn’t just assist in this process; it drives it.

Affiliate is no longer just an efficient sales channel—it’s become foundational to the next era of digital commerce.

According to eMarketer, affiliate-driven ecomm sales are set to exceed $200 billion this year, and pass $300 billion by 2029.

By 2028, affiliate marketing will account for nearly one out of every $7 spent online.

And that, by the way, is massive.

It means the affiliate is one of the most powerful forces in marketing.

The sheer scale of it makes affiliate marketing one of the largest, and most important ad channels in the digital ecosystem. 

But now AI is changing how affiliate marketing operates and, more importantly, who controls discovery. And as AI begins to reshape how products, creators, and audiences find each other, an essential question arises…

If AI is handling discovery, how do we maintain the human touch that keeps the partnerships working?

The New Era

Affiliate marketing is built on relationships.

Brands would traditionally seek out the right creators, negotiate partnerships, and measure performance through clicks and conversions.

But the explosion of creator content has made the old methods unsustainable.

Managing a small program of creators was doable with a spreadsheet and a small team, but now people are trying to do the same with thousands of creators—and for that, they turn to AI.

AI can scan creator performance data, audience overlap, engagement signals—and even tone of voice— to discover optimal new partners at scale.

But the best partnerships are still born from a combination of automation and empathy.

So this shift with AI does present some new and exciting opportunities for both brands and affiliates.

When AI Becomes the Affiliate

Here’s where things get interesting—and a bit disruptive.

AI chatbots, like ChatGPT, are now used more often than browsers or search engines. And the fastest-growing category of queries? Shopping.

Consumers aren’t typing “which are the best wireless headphones?” into Google anymore—they’re going straight to AI. Meaning AI has fast become both a discovery channel and a recommendation engine.

So what does that mean for affiliates?

According to Max Willens, a senior analyst at eMarketer, as AI becomes more prominent in the consumer shopping journey, creativity and experimentation will be key.

In a recent webinar hosted by eMarketer, Stephanie Harris, Founder & CEO of New York marketing agency, PartnerCentric referred to something she calls, “AI Public Relations”— which is a focus on creating content that’s machine-readable, structured, credible, and verifiable so that it becomes part of what the AI large language models (LLMs) learn from.

“Traditional SEO strategies are just not working in today’s world,” she said. “Brands and affiliates are all needing to think about how they can get their content more visible in a world that’s shifting from Google ranking, to visibility in the language models.”

In many cases, those AI shopping suggestions are actually already coming from affiliate content.

In fact, Zenni Optical found that 70% of its mentions in LLM chats were attributable to affiliate content.

That’s a powerful stat—it means that affiliate content isn’t just just driving clicks anymore, it’s fueling the data that’s training AI and shaping the future of the discovery journey.

But, naturally, there’s a catch… 

When consumers shop through AI tools, the affiliate attribution can get lost. That means the link tracking, cookies, and coded partnerships that underpin affiliate revenue can disappear once funneled through a chatbot.

Not great news for affiliates. 

It does create a new challenge—but it’s also an opening for innovation.

Networks, creators, and platforms like Digistore24 are exploring smarter attribution models and integrations that preserve transparency and recognize influence—even when clicks don’t occur.

Navigating the future with AI influence means acclimatizing to a zero-click environment.

As Harris put it ever so bluntly, “last click is dead.”

In this new landscape, affiliates will need to embrace predictive attribution in order to thrive.

“Affiliate has always been a resilient channel,” said Harris. “This AI disruption is the most dynamic we’ve ever seen—and it actually makes for an exciting time.”

It’s an optimism that captures the mood of this new era: let AI handle the volume, because it’s the humans who bring the vision.

Creators: The Beating Heart of Discovery

Creators aren’t just influencers anymore — they’ve also become the new search engines.

According to eMarketer, the majority of U.S. adults say they’ve discovered a product through a creator in the past six months.

For many creators, affiliate revenue is already their third-largest source of income — after branded content and platform ad payouts — and that revenue will only continue to grow.

The affiliate model gives creators autonomy and rewards them for their authenticity.

AI tools can help affiliates spot trends, optimize content timing, and better understand their audiences. But what keeps followers coming back — and buying — isn’t the algorithm. It’s trust.

In a recent survey by PartnerCentric, 83% of respondents said they trusted influencer recommendations, but only 14% of those trust influencers more than a real person they know.

In other words, trust is the currency that drives conversion — and authenticity is the exchange rate.

That’s where the Human Touch comes in.

AI tools can predict what might resonate, but the creators still need to translate that data-driven insight into genuine, human storytelling.

Authenticity Is the New Authority

Right now, the temptation is to automate everything.

It’s a fast paced world. Attention spans are shorter. Patience is thinner. So sure, why not let the algorithms do the matching, tracking, and optimizing while we humans step back and take a bit of a breather?

Well, affiliate marketing has never really been about pure efficiency, has it? It’s about connection.

So AI can analyze what works, but only people can explain why it works—and turn that insight into a creative, authentic story.

Consumers can tell when something’s inauthentic. They want to feel like a recommendation is coming from a friend.

In fact a growing number of consumers have expressed negative sentiment toward AI-generated content, particularly in spaces that hinge on human connection, like product reviews.

Harris said that future success will mean switching from a mindset of chasing rankings, to one of chasing authenticity and credibility instead.

Just think of authenticity as the new SEO.

“That becomes authority,” she said. “That's where the shift has to happen.”

At Digistore24, we believe the next generation of affiliate marketing isn’t about replacing people with technology; it’s about amplifying human potential through it. 

AI can surface opportunities faster, personalize offers at scale, and predict trends before they peak. But affiliates still need to craft the messages, shape the values, and create the stories that make their audiences care.

AI can amplify reach, but trust is what drives conversion — and trust comes from people.

That’s why affiliates — with their unique position to provide authentic recommendations and real performance — are the perfect entity to maintain the balance.

 A Symbiotic Future for AI and Affiliate

Harris described the relationship between AI and affiliate perfectly:

“Affiliate content feeds the AI and AI feeds affiliate discovery. They’re truly symbiotic. One can’t thrive without the other.”

LLMs rely on human-generated content — reviews, comparisons, FAQs, guides — to learn. Affiliates rely on AI to surface their work, analyze engagement, and expand reach.

And both depend on consumer trust to thrive.

The rise of AI discovery doesn’t signal the end of affiliate marketing — it signals the evolution:

“Front of house should really be about the human connection,” said Harris. “That’s what builds trust and conversion. We can use AI behind the scenes to power the scale, speed, fraud detection, and matchmaking.”

Designing the Next Era of The Affiliate

So, what does adapting to this new landscape look like? Harris offered three immediate steps for brands and affiliates:

1. Be Discoverable

Structure your content for visibility in LLMs — make it machine-readable, verifiable, and rich with FAQs, comparisons, and reviews.

“We used to say, make sure you have a spotlight on your business,” said Harris. “Now: make sure that spotlight includes your competitors—and that you’re shown in a favorable light.”

2. Embrace Predictive Attribution

Move beyond last-click logic. Measure incrementality — the true impact each activity drives, even in a zero-click world.

3. Diversify Partnerships

Don’t rely on a single traffic source — build relationships across multiple channels:

And “future-proof your business,” Harris urged. “Because PPC and SEO are on the decline — and diversification is what keeps you discoverable.”

In a search environment being rewritten by AI, these are all real-world recommendations with actionable frameworks for surviving — and thriving — in the new era.

At Digistore24, we’re taking the same approach by combining automation with insight:

And every innovation is designed around one constant; keeping humans in the loop.

The Human Touch in an AI World

Affiliate marketing has always been about partnerships — between brands and creators, platform and audience, and data and intuition. AI just adds a new layer of possibility, it doesn’t replace the foundation.

The Human Touch isn’t nostalgia, it’s a business advantage. Consumers crave authenticity. They respond to voices they trust — and trust builds conversion to purchase.

AI doesn’t change that. 

At Digistore24, we see AI as an ally — a way to scale what works, but not replace what matters. 

This next chapter will depend on how we harness AI’s precision without losing the human spark that drives trust and influence.

It will be built on smarter data. But it will also rely on deep human connection. 

So AI may be reshaping the landscape, but people will always shape the story. Technology can guide discovery, but it’s humans who create the trust. 

And in the end, it’s always trust that truly drives conversion.

Want to future-proof your affiliate strategy?

Let us handle the scale. You handle the story.
With Digistore24, you can grow faster, smarter, and more authentically.

Want to become a Digistore24 affiliate? Simply go here to register for free.